Roasted Tomatoes — Devil Tomato mascotRoasted Tomatoes← BACK HOME
— COLLECTION · 25 TITLES · HORROR

Underrated Horror Movies, Ranked & Roasted

Quiet wins. The horror movies that flew under the radar but still earned a nod from our critics.

  1. 01
    Jaws poster
    Jaws· 1975
    ADVENTUREDRAMAHORROR ROAST #1 THIS WEEK
    BURN 19
    SALT 62
  2. 02
    The Thing poster
    The Thing· 1982
    HORRORMYSTERYSCI-FI CRITICS' BRAWL
    BURN 18
    SALT 63
  3. 03
    Attack on Titan: The Last Attack poster
    Attack on Titan: The Last Attack· 2024
    ANIMATIONACTIONADVENTURE CRITICS' BRAWL
    BURN 10
    SALT 66
  4. 04
    Aliens poster
    Aliens· 1986
    ACTIONADVENTUREHORROR CRITICS' BRAWL
    BURN 16
    SALT 64
  5. 05
    The Shining poster
    The Shining· 1980
    DRAMAHORROR CRITICS' BRAWL
    BURN 16
    SALT 64
  6. 06
    Alien poster
    Alien· 1979
    HORRORSCI-FI
    BURN 16
    SALT 64
  7. 07
    Psycho poster
    Psycho· 1960
    DRAMAHORRORMYSTERY
    BURN 15
    SALT 64
  8. 08
    The Silence of the Lambs poster
    The Silence of the Lambs· 1991
    CRIMEDRAMAHORROR
    BURN 14
    SALT 64
  9. 09
    Ready or Not 2: Here I Come poster
    Ready or Not 2: Here I Come· 2026
    COMEDYHORRORTHRILLER
    BURN 35
    SALT 56
  10. 10
    Idle Hands poster
    Idle Hands· 1999
    COMEDYFANTASYHORROR
    BURN 37
    SALT 55
  11. 11
    Passenger poster
    Passenger· 2026
    HORRORTHRILLER
    BURN 44
    SALT 52
  12. 12
    Sinners poster
    Sinners· 2025
    HORROR
    BURN 25
    SALT 60
  13. 13
    The Bride! poster
    The Bride!· 2026
    DRAMAHORRORROMANCE
    BURN 44
    SALT 52
  14. 14
    Colony poster
    Colony· 2026
    ACTIONADVENTURECRIME
    BURN 31
    SALT 58
  15. 15
    Saccharine poster
    Saccharine· 2026
    DRAMAHORRORSCI-FI
    BURN 39
    SALT 54
  16. 16
    Scream 7 poster
    Scream 7· 2026
    HORRORMYSTERYTHRILLER TRENDING IN THE US
    BURN 45
    SALT 52
  17. 17
    Iron Lung poster
    Iron Lung· 2026
    HORRORSCI-FI TRENDING IN THE US
    BURN 41
    SALT 54
  18. 18
    Weapons poster
    Weapons· 2025
    HORRORMYSTERY TRENDING IN THE US
    BURN 26
    SALT 60
  19. 19
    Lee Cronin's The Mummy poster
    Lee Cronin's The Mummy· 2026
    HORROR TRENDING IN THE US
    BURN 38
    SALT 55
  20. 20
    The Amazing Digital Circus: The Last Act poster
    The Amazing Digital Circus: The Last Act· 2026
    ANIMATIONADVENTURECOMEDY TRENDING IN THE US
    BURN 23
    SALT 61
  21. 21
    Bhooth Bangla poster
    Bhooth Bangla· 2026
    COMEDYHORROR TRENDING IN THE US
    BURN 45
    SALT 52
  22. 22
    Hokum poster
    Hokum· 2026
    HORRORTHRILLER TRENDING IN THE US
    BURN 32
    SALT 57
  23. 23
    They Will Kill You poster
    They Will Kill You· 2026
    ACTIONCOMEDYHORROR TRENDING IN THE US
    BURN 37
    SALT 55
  24. 24
    Backrooms poster
    Backrooms· 2026
    HORRORSCI-FITHRILLER TRENDING IN THE US
    BURN 29
    SALT 58
  25. 25
    Obsession poster
    Obsession· 2025
    HORRORROMANCETHRILLER TRENDING IN THE US
    BURN 19
    SALT 62